A post earlier at Gothamist riled me up in a way that hasn't happened since the last time I had to riff. To start, I call bullshit on Jake Dobkin, but I'll get back to that later.
The main crux of the argument is the lines between professional bloggers and hardcore blogging hobbyists (with the casual bloggers bringing up the rear). Blogs are hot in the media. News stories are all around trying to explain what it's all about and break it down for easy to digest morsels for people. People blogging about whatever can find themselves pulled up in Google and quoted in an article. If you wanted to get some fame (or infamy), there's no time greater than the present. With a little luck and ambition, you could be Elizabeth Spiers!...or so they would like people to believe.
I'm not going to lie and say that I don't operate this blog with some sort of ulterior motives. I am a writer (who doesn't write nearly enough) and I use this to sharpen my skills and stay fresh until I figure out where I want to go. But, this is a hobby. A semi-expensive hobby compared to when I was just on Geocities or Blogspot, but regardless my blog is still mostly what I've intended it to be since I started with the web stuff in 2000 -- a space so my friends and the occasional other can see what I'm thinking and for me to do little experiments. I've got my niche and I'm happy in it. I'm not trying to usurp any of the names bandied about when the quarterly "who's who in the blogosphere" article comes out. I do this because I like it and frankly, I know they've got way more dedication to this than I do.
I was amazed at the conversation going on in the comments at Gothamist where Jake demands that all bloggers reveal themselves and stand behind their names with their writing. That's the most sanctimonious piece of shit I've ever read. Hence, why I call bullshit on him. If we're going to be really honest, Gothamist is like the Disney of blogs. "Hey, guys, we're on a hunt for some good ribs!" "We went to Olive Garden!" "We love us some Law and Order!" There is nothing remotely edgy or controversial that ever occurs on those pages. It's vanilla, it's non-threatening, a snark-free zone. And that's okay. It's a clearinghouse for information on the happenings in NYC, nothing more and nothing less. Not everywhere can be tongue-in-cheek with a razor-sharp wit like most other blogs of note. But, apparently, Jake has forgotten that fact. If all I was writing about was food and what went on in the papers everyone else read, I could put my name up here too, as could a lot of other bloggers. With some obvious exceptions, it's not even that hard to figure out who most of us are. Most definitely follow the common sense rule that if it's something that could damage us, it need not be posted -- at least not in its entirety.
To have your name on your blog leaves you open not only for your employers to see what you've been up to, but relatives, ex-friends and lovers, future employers, stalkers and all sorts of other riff raff who can go fuck themselves. But, besides that, it's totally inhibiting if you want to create an online persona to accompany your blogged exploits.
The true final word on the matter is: there are no blogging rules, especially if you're someone who has gone out and bought a domain and are operating your own shit on your own time. The operating procedures are different for every blog and person. Now, someone go remove Jake's head from his ass.